1. Discussion of Joan Wynne
What does Wynne’s article tell us about linguicism and race? Why does Wynne feel we have this problem? What does Wynne believe we should do about it? What is your own take on this issue? Do you agree with Wynne or disagree? What solutions can you imagine?
2. Discussion of Hilliard
Discuss Hilliard’s analysis of the origins of Ebonics? Why does Hilliard believe it should NOT be called “Black English”? What does Hilliard regard as the most important issue here. Do you agree or disagree with her?
3. Discussion of Ernie Smith
Describe Ernie Smith’s journey. What aspects of his experience stand out to you? What do you think his story tells us about racism and linguicism?
4. Discussion of Smitherman
What does Geneva Smitherman believe we should do as part of a national policy on
language? Do you agree or disagree? Why or why not? What do you think a national
policy on language should be?